Showing posts with label Ethnic supremacism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ethnic supremacism. Show all posts

Monday, August 31, 2026

Foreword to 'De-democratisation, A Global Story' by Kavita Krishnan

A quarter of the way through the twenty-first century – when Israel, with the US in tow, is committing genocide in Palestine and ethnic cleansing in Lebanon, bombing Syria and carpet-bombing Iran with the complicity of Western powers, barring only Spain and Norway – it’s tempting to go along with the view that we are witnessing a struggle between ‘the West and the Rest’, and the Left should stand with ‘the Rest’. But that would be a grave mistake, according to Kavita Krishnan.

In her book De-democratisation, A Global Story: Script, Actors, Enablers (Context/Westland Books, 2026), she engages in a forensic analysis which demonstrates how Trump’s US, Netanyahu’s Israel, Putin’s Russia, Xi Jinping’s China, Modi’s India and Orban’s Hungary constitute a network connected by ideology, politics and mutual support. The ideology they share is what she calls ‘civilisational nationalism’, underpinned by the politics of ‘multipolarity’, which either explicitly abandons democracy or redefines it as a politics of ethnic or ethno-religious supremacism practised by the powerful nations which form the ‘poles’, allowing them to oppress women and minorities within the country and dominate or colonise less powerful countries abroad. They provide political, economic and ideological support to each other: for example, she shows how Xi’s China plays a critical role in bolstering Israel’s genocide in Gaza, just as Modi’s India is also fully complicit in it.

What led her to write this book is the fact that most of the Left, including many iconic spokespeople, subscribe to multipolarity. She counters their criticisms of liberal democracy by showing that it is a product of struggles by oppressed sections of the population, above all workers and trade unions, and that international law, as represented in the Genocide Convention, Universal Declaration of Human Rights and Rome Statute of the ICC, is also shaped by anti-colonial, feminist and anti-racist struggles.

It is true that supposedly liberal political leaders constantly violate human rights, democracy and international law, but if they profess these principles, they can be held to account. Similarly, socialist leaders may violate socialist principles, but if they profess them, they can be held accountable. For example Lenin, like Marx and Engels, held that democracy was an essential precondition for socialism, and although he fell short of living up to this standard, he criticised himself for doing so, and died fighting for the right of all colonies, including tsarist ones like Ukraine, to self-determination, thus making himself Putin’s worst enemy. For the Left to abandon these principles in favour of multipolarity is a complete betrayal of socialist politics.

What happens when one of these poles clashes with another, as in the case of the US–Israeli war of aggression against the Islamic Republic of Iran, which just a few weeks earlier was slaughtering its own people engaged in peaceful protests and had brutally crushed previous uprisings, including the Woman Life Freedom movement? Here we have to depend on the notion of intersectionality developed by Black feminists. We can support democracy protesters against the Islamic Republic even while we support the people of Iran as a whole against US–Israeli aggression: there is no contradiction between these two positions, they both support the victim of oppression against the oppressor. Krishnan concludes that ‘the most urgent battle of our times is between the defenders and destroyers of democracy. The de-democratisers of the world have joined forces against democracy as a universal principle. Their project can be defeated only if we – people across the world – reclaim democratic principles as our shared inheritance.’

 

 


Friday, September 5, 2025

'To See In The Dark' by Nicholas Mirzoeff

 

Nicholas Mirzoeff is Professor of Media, Culture and Communication at New York University and a theorist and practitioner of visual culture. In To See In the Dark: Palestine and Visual Activism Since October 7, he introduces himself by saying, ‘I’m Jewish and I’m anti-Zionist… To be an anti-Zionist Jew requires overcoming the combined efforts of the state of Israel, Zionism, and white supremacy to make this identity impossible. For the US magazine The Tablet, anti-Zionists like me are “un-Jews.”’

Mirzoeff explains the metaphor of ‘seeing in the dark’ as seeing outside the space dominated by the white-supremacist settler-colonial way of seeing. The IDF’s ‘white sight’ has defined all of Gaza as a kill box, whereas ‘To see in the dark is to see outside the kill box… Seeing in the dark is the practice of solidarity, the means by which to see how colonialism is practiced.’

Palestinians play an indispensable leading role in the visual activism that makes the genocide visible to the rest of the world, risking and all-too-often losing their lives to capture scenes of horror and cruelty but also the love and care with which survivors are searched for, rescued and treated by humanitarian and medical staff. For those who identify spontaneously with an anti-colonial struggle, these images immediately establish an emotional link with the victims. For colonisers and their descendants, especially Jews, identification is not so easy. Mirzoeff notes that ‘The intensity with which some Jews have identified with Israel is also part of their claim to be on the dominant side of racial hierarchy.’ Mirzoeff repudiated that impulse, his grandmother did not. On the boat to Palestine around 1923 she was a refugee, but by the time she stepped off she had metamorphosed into a settler, becoming a fighter in the Haganah, the Jewish militia that became the core of the IDF.  

Anti-Zionist Jews have the unique ability to dismantle Zionism from the inside and to say things that non-Jews cannot say without being suspected of antisemitism. Mirzoeff can say that the International Holocaust Remembrance Association’s definition of antisemitism is itself antisemitic; attack as ‘patently anti-Jewish’ the view that without Israeli state sovereignty Jews are necessarily weak; identify the feeling of being physically unsafe among Jewish New Yorkers and students after 7 October as emanating from their identification with the settler-colonial violence of the Israeli state; point out that the UN conclusion that sexual violence probably occurred during the 7 October attack was reached without any evidence; and say that Palestinian Jews and non-Jews lived together peacefully before Zionism and could do so after Zionism ends. Josh Dubnau agrees: ‘There were Jews thousands of years before Zionism and there will be Jews when Zionism is in the dustbin of history.’ Masha Gessen compares the genocide in Gaza to the Nazi liquidation of East European ghettos, and Gabor Maté compares it with Auschwitz. They all make an essential contribution to the struggle for a free Palestine.

(This review was part of the Palestine Book Forum published by Postmodern Culture on 5 September 2025 and available at https://muse.jhu.edu/pub/1/article/968576)  

Thursday, June 2, 2022

Socialist Internationalism and the Ukraine War

How do the working people of the world transform themselves from a plethora of groups waging a multitude of scattered struggles for survival and dignity to a revolutionary force capable of ending capitalism, governing the earth, and taking over production? They have innumerable tasks before them, but one of the most important is to overcome divisions among themselves resulting from ethnic supremacism and nationalism. Marxists have been debating this issue from the beginning, but it still plagues us today. The war in Ukraine offers a good opportunity to examine it more closely.

Tribute to D. Thankappan

  I have known Comrade Thankappan since he was leading the Kamani Employees’ Union. I interviewed him extensively about his pioneering wor...